top of page

​

Session 6

​

​

Session 6- The 3Ds: Diversity, Dissemination and Disclosure of Heritage.

Session 6- The 3Ds: Diversity, Dissemination and Disclosure of Heritage.

Session 6- The 3Ds: Diversity, Dissemination and Disclosure of Heritage.
Introduction. The 3Ds: Diversity, Dissemination and Disclosure of Heritage.

Introduction. The 3Ds: Diversity, Dissemination and Disclosure of Heritage.

05:04
3D Models as Tools for the People.

3D Models as Tools for the People.

15:08
3D Techniques: Disseminating Climate Impacts through Archaeological Heritage.

3D Techniques: Disseminating Climate Impacts through Archaeological Heritage.

15:41

Paper Abstracts 

​

3D Models as Tools for the People

Aida Loy, Independent researcher, Leiden University

​

3D models are a common tool within the archaeological and heritage community. But most of the time those 3D models and reconstructions do not leave the academic sphere, even when they could be great tools to communicate and engage with the non-specialised audience. To try and show how useful these models I would present a model and the work that was done with it as an engagement tool. As a model, I use a 3D reconstruction of an Iron Age hillfort in Asturias (Spain). This reconstruction shows how the hillfort would look like in the Iron Age according to the last archaeological evidence. As for the engagement part, I will present the results of some surveys conducted on and off-site. The surveys were done to three groups of stakeholders after seeing the model and they threw light on how we could improve the communication between digital archaeologists and the general audience.

​

​

3D Techniques: Disseminating Climate Impacts Through Archaeological Heritage

Ellie Graham, University of Aberdeen

​

As climate change impacts societies, infrastructure and assets, its effects on cultural heritage are accelerating, with rising temperatures, rising sea levels, increasing precipitation and more extreme weather events damaging buildings, sites and landscapes. The Scotland’s Coastal Heritage at Risk Project (2012-2016) carried out by the SCAPE Trust engaged volunteers from local coastal communities to record and monitor vulnerable archaeological sites threatened by erosion. By taking a citizen science approach to the issue of heritage loss, this appealed to the public to contribute to the solution by undertaking the task of recording and monitoring vulnerable sites. The creation of an interactive website and mobile app democratised participation and facilitated engagement from the design of the project, the collection of data to the dissemination of the results of the research, illustrating to a network of volunteers, participants and stakeholders how Scotland’s rich coastal archaeological resource is threatened by climate change impacts. Building upon this, new doctoral research aims to examine ways in which threatened coastal sites can be further researched and the impacts of climate change tracked through the deployment of emerging remote sensing techniques. Recent developments of online platforms for sharing data provide portals to communicate information both about heritage and about the impacts of climate change. Additionally, volunteerparticipation in field research and ground truthing results can strengthen public engagement. This paper will explore the potential of heritage under threat from climate impacts to engage communities both with local coastal heritage and the wider climate debate.

​

​

Trowels and Bones: Using Twine to Tell Stories about the Mycenaeans

Despoina Vasiliki Sampatakou, University of York

​

The aim of this paper is to present a Twine game I recently made - and still working on - as part of my PhD research. The aim of my research is to understand how to create more impactful interpretive experiences of the past as well as how to convey life histories through embodied interpretations of archaeological remains. My case study is the individuals buried at Grave Circle A, a Bronze Age cemetery in Mycenae, Greece, and the core project isto create three stories using different media but with the same storyline and details: the first is a classic narrative story, the second is a more interactive one created with Twine, and the third one will be an immersive experience in a 3D environment. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the benefits and limitations of Twine and archaeogaming in general when telling stories about people in the past.

​

​

Can Digital Technology Redress War Crimes Against Cultural Patrimony?

Luca Ottonello, University of Glasgow

​

This paper will start by listing and analysing some case studies of some of the major crimes against cultural monuments and institutions between this and last century; giving a summary of what was lost and how. It will then move onto looking at the different ways proposed and adapted by both national and international associations in an effort to redress the damage that was done using digital means or alternatively at some of the available digital technology that could be used to aid in the analysed cases.The focus question will be if all these proposed solutions are viable and if they should actually be used according to interested parties like the local communities, the international cultural associations and the scientific community; or if in alternative there would be no point in taking such actions due to the nature of what was destroyed. By the end of this paper the discussion will turn towards concluding which ones are the most viable solutions to this conundrum and reasons why, dependent on the results of the analysis on both the crimes and the proposed digital technology to be implemented and at the same time list the reasons why some might not work in order to assess the overall effectiveness of such an approach.Keywords: history, digital archaeology, historical games, Palmyra, terrorism, redressing, reconstruction, 3D printing, international cultural associations, ethics, culture, refugees, war, crimes against cultural heritage.

​

​

A Middle Ground for Difficult Heritage: Commemorating Lynching via the Equal Justice Initiative’s National Memorial for Peace and Justice and Community Remembrance Project

Kirsten Huffer, University of Cambridge

​

This research focuses on how top-down and bottom-up processes interface in multi-scalar civil society organization (CSO) initiatives commemorating difficult heritage. Drawing on the concept of hybrid forums (Callon et al., 2011) within a dialogical model of heritage (Harrison, 2013), this research unpicks how effectively the aforementioned processes may together mediate place-based postmemories. It delves into the case of the Equal Justice Initiative’s (EJI) National Memorial for Peace and Justice and Community Remembrance Project (CRP). By critically examining the online presences, historical markers, other primary sources, and media coverage of CRP coalitions nationwide, in the context of EJI’s online presence, this research reveals inextricably linked top-down and bottom-up, national and grassroots, commemorative processes, which this dissertation theorizes constitute a hybrid middle ground. While coalitions support grassroots discourses and local emplacement of difficult heritage, the coordination of these initiatives via a CSO-led nationwide initiative offers a coherent narrative that mediates and reinforces subaltern community discourses. This research concludes that the middle ground can scale dialogical decision-making practices in ways that have the potential to more effectively commemorate place-based postmemories--and at times subvert hegemonic discourses--than top-down or bottom-up processes alone, thus offering new understandings of how difficult heritage may be commemorated.

​

​

Redeeming the Dust:

The Temple Mount Sifting Project and The Problem of Participatory Heritage

Fridtjof Leemhuis, MF - Norwegian School of Theology, Religion and Society

​

The Temple Mount Sifting Project (TMSP) might not have the long list of academic publications that other archaeological projects and excavations in Jerusalem do. Still, it has existed for more than 15 years and maintains a robust media presence. The TMSP claims to be the first archaeological project with exclusive access to the soil of the Temple Mountain/Haram Al-Sharif, employs a considerable number of tourists and volunteers, and is supported by high profile political interest groups. Zachi Dvira and renowned archaeologist Gabriel Barkay began operating a public archaeological sifting site in 2004. So far they claim to have sifted through 75% of roughly 400 truckloads of alleged Temple Mount soil. Over the past 15 years more than 200,000 volunteers have participated in the sifting. The TMSP offers 2-hour sifting events through their homepage, including a 30min introduction into the sifting practice and a 90min sifting activity at one of their 30 Wet- sifting stations. This papers aims to present a brief overview on the history, questionable practice and contested political background of the TMSP, before discussing the ethics of participatory archaeology. For the TMSP the hands- on approach is not only a source of income but also an important tool for their one-sided storytelling. And although the TMSP might be an extreme example of participatory archaeology gone wrong, it helps us to asks important questions about the ethical implications of money, storytelling, emotions and their significant role in the design of public heritage.

​

​

Living and Understanding Together: How Can We Foster More Informative and Inclusive Public Outreach at Göbekli Tepe?

Ekin Berk Polat, Koç University

​

Towards the end of 2019, the Year of Göbekli Tepe, billboards of Istanbul were adorned by a mysterious symbol that was advertising the second Turkish series on Netflix: The Gift. It excited Turkish public as the first archaeological science fiction series ever shot in the country, which became a hit shortly after its release. Nevertheless, there is a price for growing popularity. Over the years, Göbekli Tepe has faced various peaks of pseudo-archaeological interpretations. Several documentaries and books including “Magicians of the Gods”, “Ancient Aliens”, “Cradle of the Gods”and many more, which are highly non-academic, eventually surpassed scientific research. A survey about the relation between archaeology and the public in Turkey shows that %37 percent of the population gain knowledge about archaeology through television, which also makes problematic documentaries more visible compared to scientific research. A website and online blog launched by German Archaeological Institute as part of the Göbekli Tepe Project for beating those narratives seem not to have achieved the same popularity. The need for further public involvement to increase scientific community outreach of the cultural heritage also remains inadequate as it lacks community development and diverse awareness raising projects. Therefore, the issue of public outreach at the site becomes more prominent in terms of preventing pseudo-archaeological narratives. This study aims to investigate current trends regarding the outreach at Göbekli Tepe and discusses how archaeologists and stakeholders can develop better outreach projects while allowing diverse understandings of neolithization in Anatolia and sedentism in complex communities.

​

​

The Way of St James: Diversity, Dissemination and Disclosure of Jacobean Heritage

Sergio Larrauri Redondo, Instituto de Estudios Riojanos

​

The pilgrimage routes to Santiago de Compostela are alive in these first decades of the XXI century. You only need to go out into the streets of our Jacobean villages to perceive it: posters, pilgrim shelters, metal plaques on the ground indicating the itinerary, people from all over the world dressed with backpacks on which the significant scallops hang, cultural diversity...The recovery of the practice of the pilgrimage of medieval origin to Santiago de Compostela is present in our society, in our towns, not only in a religious or spiritual meaning, but rather because of their tourist, heritage, cultural or personal experience values. Its resurgence has been a complex process for which we must go back the second half of the 20th. This “Jacobean renaissance” was consolidated in the 80s and 90s thanks to various international factors such as the appointment of the Camino de Santiago as the First European Cultural Itinerary by the Council of Europe (1987) or its declaration as a World Heritage Site by the UNESCO (1993). Within Spain, numerous actions have also been carried out to consolidate pilgrimage routes to Compostela, such as the Xacobeos celebrations, the arrangement and signaling of roads, the creation of shelters or the adaptation of a network of Jacobean routes. But undoubtedly other main elements that contribute to the rebirth of the pilgrimages to Compostela are its heritage wealth, the diversity, dissemination and disclosure of the Jacobean heritage.

​

​

Learners, Players, and Pearl Divers: An Investigation of Pearling Activities in East Asia in the Context of Archaeological Virtual Reality Game-Based Learning.

Yuxi Xie, University of Oxford

​

This paper demonstrates a research on how virtual reality game-based learning can contribute to the public archaeology by using pearl diving as a case study. The dissertation presents a two-part approach: An in-depth review at a wide range of study from Public Archaeology, Education and Game Design, and a data collection that focused on different traits of pearl divers from research in Biology, Archaeology, Anthropology and other social science subjects. By evaluating how virtual reality-based games could help the public to learn about pearling in East Asia, the dissertation suggested that it might be one of the most effective applications in public archaeological outreach. In addition, the dissertation reveals information on pearl diving activities in East Asian regions that have rarely or not been discussed yet by the English academic world. It is concluded that the data presented here will be valuable to both archaeological digital-game based learning and academical studies on pearling activities.

​

​

The 4-D in Archaeology: Diversity, Dissemination, Disclosure and Diversion (Fun).

New Concepts in Heritage Teaching

Isaac Martínez Espinosa & Belén Martínez Pérez, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid & Instituto

de Estudios Riojanos

​

In recent years, archaeological and historical dissemination have been adapted to new educational trends based on greater student participation in order to expand their skills in the world of the humanities.Urraca, as a heritage research group, has focused part of its work on the creation of educational activities and resources using various recycled materials, using games and modern educational techniques to carry out a very novel bet in La Rioja.In this proposal, we will deal with the diversity of activities used for the dissemination of heritage elaborated for the centennial CVNE winery (in its fifth generation) and the great and interesting project that they are going to carry out with the restoration of the Davalillo Castle acquired in 2019.This work, in which the interest of the winery and its project for the sensitivity of a region and the recovery of a part of its historical, archaeological, architectural and intangible heritage that would otherwise have been lost, has been designed through a proposal not previously seen, laying the foundations of respect for heritage from the beginning of the project. This interest is what makes the Davalillo Castle of CVNE and Urraca’s proposal, one of the regional references concerning the care and disclosure of heritage. Keywords: Archaeology, Diversity, Heritage, Disclosure and Education

​

casa logo.png

CASA

Cambridge Annual Student Archaeology Conference

  • Untitled-1 small
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

 © 2022 by CASA Team. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page